Justice Frank Seepersad

SECTIONS ARCHAIC:Justice Frank Seepersad

TWENTY-NINE grounds of appeal have been mounted by the State as it challenges last Monday’s ruling by Justice Frank Seepersad that the country’s colonial-age sedition laws were unconstitutional.

An additional five grounds are being relied upon as they relate to a substitution order in which the judge allowed Vijay Maharaj, the son of former Sanatan Dharma Maha Sabha (SDMS) secretary general Sat Maharaj, to replace his father as a claimant in the proceedings.

The appeal was filed at the Hall of Justice in Port of Spain on Monday evening, exactly one week after Justice Seepersad ruled that sections 3 and 4 of the Sedition Act, which came into effect in 1920, were not in conformity with the Constitution as they imposed disproportionate and unjustified restrictions on citizens’ free speech, expression and thought.

The judge also held that the act infringed on the right to freedom of the press.

Following the ruling, Attorney General Faris Al-Rawi said the ruling of the judge was “dange­rous” and indicated it would be appealed all the way to the Privy Council in London, England.

In his ruling, Justice Seepersad said sections 3 and 4 of the Sedition Act were patently inconsistent and were at odds with Section 1 of the Constitution, which guarantees that Trinidad and Tobago is a sovereign, democratic State.

“In addition, they violate the Rule of Law because they lack certain­ty, are vague and so their status as law cannot be reasonably justified in this sovereign, democra­tic state,” the judge said.

No sedition charge

The effect of the ru­ling is that people can no longer be charged with the act of sedi­tion unless Justice Seeper­sad’s ruling is overturned at appeal.

The ruling also brought an immediate halt to a preli­mi­nary enquiry against Watson Duke, president of the Public Services Associa­tion (PSA), who was charged with se­dition last August over statements he made during a protest at telecoms provider TSTT in 2018.

When the appeal comes up for hearing, attorneys for the Office of the Attorney Gene­ral will seek to have the court set aside both the substitution of Sat Maharaj with his son and substantive orders of Justice Seepersad pending the hearing and determination of the appeal.

That application was also made before See­per­sad after the judgment was delivered, but it was denied.

The constitutional claim was filed by Maha­raj and his media company, Central Broadcasting Services Ltd, af­ter Maharaj made certain statements on his Maha Sabha Strikes Back programme on TV Jaagriti on April 15, 2019.

Maharaj said citizens living in Tobago were lazy and the men were rapists.

Even though he had not been charged, Maharaj later suggested to his supporters during an SDMS Indian Arri­val Day celebration that a charge for sedition against him was inevitable.


Trinidad-born rapper Nicki Minaj shared her life’s struggles with love, violence and drugs with the girls at the St Jude’s Home in Belmont yesterday.

THE Caribbean is on high alert for the deadly Covid-19 after the first case of the new coronavirus was confirmed in Latin America.

On February 26, the Ministry of Health of Brazil confirmed the country’s first case of Covid-19.

IN the face of a sharp increase in the number of new COVID-19 (coronavirus) cases outside China, which for the first time has exceeded new cases ­within ­China, the Government yesterday widened the ­14-day travel restriction list to include Singapore, Italy, Japan, Iran and South Korea.

With the success of their “Stage Gone Bad” collaboration, reigning Road March champs Kees Dieffenthaller and Neil “Iwer” George are looking forward to more collaborations next year.