Theodore Lewis

Professor Theodore Lewis

I seek to offer some reflections on the influences of Sat Maharaj. I am drawing on education because it is the discipline that has conditioned much of my professional life and my travels, which include two trips to India, both enabled by my colleague, Prof Rohit Dhankar of Azim Premjie university in Bangalore.

These conferences (2014, 2016), had to do with philosophy of education, involving a searching among Indian intellectuals for ways to convince Indian leaders education had to become a more highly valued good, and a key to addressing the uncomfortable question of exclusion of the schedule classes.

As fate would have it, Sat Maharaj died as the CAPE scholarship results were being published. Make no mistake, Sat’s Hindu schools are really not schools of Hindi. These are not the equivalent of madrasas. They are academic enclaves. They follow the SEA, CSEC and CAPE syllabi.

The wrinkle here is that Sat had a chip on his shoulder about his schools. Much like the legend of Charles Atlas, the skinny youth in whose face sand was once kicked, Sat brooded over Eric Williams’ supposed reference to his schools as cow sheds. That slight, he said, was the motivator for his drive to improve Hindu schools.

This really is not an acceptable pretext upon which to found schools. But in any case, in my view there was a gaping flaw in that folksy cow-shed story, to be seen in the fact of Naparima Girls’, and in St Augustine Girls’ High School, these two top schools having 90.6 per cent and 71.3 per cent, respectively, of their 2019 intake being Indian girls. Or, in Iere High School in Siparia, which produced in Kamla Persad-­Bissessar the first woman prime minister of this country. Or Holy Faith Convent in Couva, for which 54.2 per cent of pupils taken in this year after SEA were Indian girls. Or Holy Faith Convent, Penal, which had an intake of Indian girls this year of 59.6 per cent. Or Bishop Anstey, Port of Spain, which produced Dana Seetahal.

Not to mention that Indian children abound in Government schools. More to the point, the Indian girls who attend the convents or the Presbyterian schools are largely Hindu. Less than ten per cent of Indians are Presbyterians. I attended Harmony Hall Presbyterian School, and we sang Hindi songs there.

Sat’s disposition was that Hindu schools had to be ethnic enclaves and hence exclusionary. And the SDMS did not conform to Ministry of Education dictates. When I chaired the Cabinet committee on the elementary curriculum, the Education Ministry called a meeting of representatives of all the denominations to be given an update. The SDMS did not send a ­representative. Other denominations, including SWAHA, did.

It cannot be said, by anybody, that Eric ­Williams suppressed the education of Indian girls and boys. I think members of the two races were equal sufferers. The winners always were the one-percenters. I was in Seventh Standard, in the year when it seemed that the College Exhibition floodgates had opened, maybe 1959, and all places in the denominational schools became non-paying. I did not benefit from this, being just slightly over 12.

I instead went to Southern Polytechnic, a private secondary school. These private schools—Ideal, Progressive, Osmond, St Johns, St Thomas Aquinas, Kenley’s, Renown—had more children than the established schools. Many were run by Indian principals/owners. There was no racial bias at entry. Your parents paid your school fees. They were money-­making places that turned no one away.

I sat in classes with Indian children throughout my secondary school life. It was the same when I attended John Donaldson and Mausica Teachers College. Naparima Teachers Training College was all Indian.

In an Express column of Sunday, September 9, titled “Two Trinidad and Tobagos”, my colleague Prof Selwyn Cudjoe expressed “hurt” at the fact that the Government seemed at ease with the spectre of Franklin Khan’s energy interns, five of 29 of them being Africans. He wrote: “As a leader who is committed to the elimination of covert discrimination, it would be nice to hear Kamla’s response, in concrete terms, to this nagging problem that is endemic to our society.”

I think the facts on the ground in this country go against Sat’s core pretext, which is that of the downtrodden Indian. Look at the scholarship results this year and black children are ­nowhere to be found. With PNM the Government.

I knew the society when Indians lived in carat houses. Meanwhile, blacks were living in shacks and barrack rooms in Port of Spain, and indeed, next to the labasse in shanty town. I was born in Laventille, where houses were all shacks. Indians today live in places like Palmiste, Valsayn and Lange Park, and no one there knows what a carat house is.

Sat was very much a politician, as Raffique Shah has long pointed out. He is an agent provocateur, crying wolf all the time. On Patrick Manning’s death, he deemed the former prime minister to have been a racist. He was acutely aware of the politics of the country, and cautioned Kamla that he controlled the “Hindu vote”. She, in turn, in life and death, paid him homage. As prime minister, she did him the favour of designating Lakshmi Girls’ to be one of two Samsung Smart schools, allowing it (along with her alma mater, Iere High School) to be wired as model technology-equipped schools.

His obstinacy turned on the fact that his people had his back. Near the end, he kept spoiling for a fight. Pleading with Gary Griffith to have the cops arrest him for sedition.

He did not obey anybody, and certainly not State authority. I thought he did not handle the “Massive” controversy well.

As to the scholarships this year, Sat’s pride and joy Lakshmi Girls’ got 40, but Tobago across all schools got a total of two. Sat would have an explanation for that. More to the point, many of his followers in the society would see nothing in this. Just another occasion for the racial triumphalism as modelled by Sat across his life. Their side is the winner, consistent with the separatist logic underpinning Sat’s legacy.

—Theodore Lewis is Professor ­Emeritus, University of Minnesota. He chaired the Cabinet Committee on the school ­curriculum.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Public confidence in any government is not helped when the family of a senior government minister is the beneficiary of State contacts. In the case of Attorney General Faris Al-Rawi, contracts to his relatives run to over $20 million a year for the rental of property, according to an exclusive Sunday Express report. Put in context, this works out to 8.5 per cent of the State’s annual bill for the rental of private property.

I wish to thank the endorsers of the statement on the “Education of Children of African Origin” articles that appeared in this paper recently. The statement rightly raised several issues of inequality in access to quality education in T&T, by black children (among others).

Every employee in Trinidad and Tobago, regardless of if they work in the public or private sector, is entitled by law to certain rights.

I have been working with the United Nations on Violence against the Women/Gender-Based Violence for the past ten years in Africa, the Arab world, and Eastern Europe. And in Trinidad and Tobago we have had one of those recent uproars over the killing of women and the search for causes. And the primary cause stares us in the face.

The state of existence as a tribalist is when one is living with a distinctive characteristic so as to be identified with a particular identifiable distinctive group. This status quo surfaces to facilitate the tribal member who is excessively loyal to his own group. 

LISTENING to President Paula-Mae Weekes’s address on the reopening of the Red House, even the most sceptical among us could not help but be impressed, indeed be moved, by her departure on the role she was expected to play and the sentiments she was expected to express as head of officialdom, to be a spokesperson for the people on the ground pointing to their “hurt” and the inability of the leadership to address this hurt.