Express Editorial : Daily

Almost five decades after it last emerged as a matter of headline public concern, the charge of sedition once again signals a deplorably negative official attitude towards freedom of expression.

It was back in 1972 that the Mighty Sparrow had recorded a calypso warning, inspired by the Public Order Act infamously promoted by then attorney general Karl Hudson-Phillips. “Sedition, careful,” Sparrow sang. “Careful how you talking…/Your right or your left hand/Raise it, it’s straight apprehension/And police detention, charged with sedition…”.

All of a sudden, high-profile public figures are being investigated and are facing threats of prosecution for being too loose with their tongues for the likes of listeners in official positions. Police interest in Messrs Sat Maharaj and Watson Duke follow several instances in which words and actions by opposition activists were loosely labelled “unpatriotic”, “treasonous” and described as “worthy of criminal investigation and may qualify as the serious crime of sedition”, by no less influential a figure than National Security Minister Stuart Young.

This newspaper has previously recorded our discomfort with Minister Young’s instinct for extreme conclusions and his all too casual references to crimes against the State, rendered more concerning since his is the line ministry for the country’s security personnel and apparatus.

It remains unclear exactly which official figures are taking offence over what is judged to be intolerably extreme expressions on matters of public affairs. But Sanatan Dharma Maha Sabha (SDMS) head Sat Maharaj has suffered the experience of two searches of his radio and TV Jaagriti station and related offices, allegedly in pursuit of evidence relevant to sedition charge or charges. Such charges have ostensibly been contemplated in response to distasteful on-air remarks by the controversial figure.

Disturbingly, it has taken months, and costly litigation, before Mr Maharaj could be allowed to see one of the warrants authorising search of his Central Broadcasting premises. The message came across clearly: sedition charges constitute a real and present danger to all who would give their mouths liberty on presumably sensitive matters of public affairs.

Get caught up with news from the news leader
Subscribe now and get access to the Trinidad Express E-paper
SUBSCRIBE/ LOG IN

The Maharaj sedition affair was still making the rounds of public curiosity when colourfully outspoken Public Services Association (PSA) president and Tobago House of Assembly Minority Leader Watson Duke attracted police attention supposedly for remarks uttered months before. In the Duke case, matters went further than with Mr Maharaj; Mr Duke was last night charged with sedition.

Nobody knows what further detriment such charges and or investigations might incur but intimidatory effect is been realised by the police searches and detentions. Police Commissioner Gary Griffith denies any political pressure has led to the police actions against Messrs Maharaj and Duke. But that is hardly any consolation for public and other figures moved to exercise a constitutional right to free expression in word spoken and written.

Is sedition to be considered a new, or renewed, menace to the exercise of freedom of speech and press? The public, outspoken members in particular, and newspapers, which are a special focus of the Sedition Act, urgently need to know.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

The issues raised over the BBC report earlier this week and the Prime Minister’s characterisation of the role of the BBC brings into sharp focus the question of the Government’s view of TTT’s role in Trinidad and Tobago. Critics of the Government are already tempted to transcribe the personal opinions of the BBC onto the similar Government-owned entity in T&T.

This September season the BBC proudly presents a reboot of the classic sitcom Allo Allo, now retitled “Allo Allo: The T&T Reboot”.

Against the background of vulnerability of prison officers to criminal retaliation—detailed by the Prison Officers Association (POA) and brought into sharp focus by high-profile and sometimes deadly attacks on officers outside prison walls—National Security Minister Stuart Young made good on his promise this week.

The Minister of Finance, Colm Imbert, has his plate full to deal with a network of social, economic and infrastructural issues for Trinidad and Tobago.

I am aware of about 12 people, all under 40 years of age, who have either migrated, are in the process of migrating, or taking the necessary steps to migrate. All of them are university graduates, some with Master’s degrees.