The attempt by the Police Service Commission (PolSC) to use social media—with all its known data deficiencies—to evaluate and assess the Commissioner of Police (CoP) is seriously flawed and possibly irresponsible, given its constitutional mandate.

The CoP himself has a fan club with clear implications for this social media survey. The responses, including anonymous ones, to the PolSC can be manipulated in many ways, producing a very unreliable and invalid result. The PolSC survey will be working against a high well-known level of public relations and a lot of self-praise by the Commissioner.

The public is also faced with Police Service data on crime reports without telling the public the percentage of detection, etc. The detection rates are deterrents to crime. Covid-19 has a strong influence on crime reports. These are additional reasons for the PolSC to do its job properly. Uncontrolled social media survey is seriously flawed for this purpose.

Public confidence and trust in the Police Service and its leadership are critical for crime reduction, management and the preservation of human rights. In recent years, many serious concerns have been expressed about problems in each one, so that today as the PolSC undertakes its constitutional assessment of the Commissioner’s performance and leadership, a very reliable method of such assessment is required.

It must be a method by the PolSC with which the public itself has confidence and trust. If the public does not have confidence in the PolSC method, how can it have trust in the results of the CoP’s performance?

The PolSC had complained that it does not have the required funds to undertake a reliable and randomised sample. Just as the Government provides millions of dollars to advertise and hire private consultants to develop interview methods for selecting ­applicants for the CoP post, why can’t it provide the required funds for the PolSC to do a reliable, valid and trustworthy public survey?

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

On January 8, 2019, I received a letter from the Board of Inland Revenue (BIR) advising that my returns for the income years 2013 and 2017 were under examination. I submitted my income tax returns electronically, via e-Tax, they were assessed, approved, and I received my refunds in the mail.

I read the letter titled “Trump is dangerous, Americans must vote him out” (Express, October 10) by Christian Pereira, parish priest at St Benedict’s, La Romaine, in which he spews falsehoods pertaining to US president Donald Trump and his administration.

I am writing this a few days after the 49th anniversary of the second state of emergency that Dr Eric Williams imposed on the National Joint Action Committee (NJAC) and other progressive groups, October 19, 1971, and the 37th anniversary of the execution of Grenadian prime minister Maurice Bishop on October 19, 1983.

Most of the countries in North, Central and South America have been hugely impacted by the Transatlantic Slave Trade. None more so than the US, where this ultra violent, heinous, wicked and totally dehumanising institution was finally abolished in 1865 after fighting a civil war over the matter, where the southern states were on the side of keeping slavery alive.

The British pantomime is a traditional Christmas entertainment in which stock characters face imaginary dangers and audience participation is encouraged (“He’s behind you!”), but the play never frightens the children and it always has a happy ending.

A debt of gratitude is owed to the teenagers who led the challenge that forced a much-needed review of the Caribbean Examinations Council (CXC). The value of their efforts is now evident in the final report released yesterday by the review team, headed by Hazel Simmons-McDonald, which was tasked to examine changes in the administration and grading process of this year’s CSEC and CAPE exams and the moderation process applied to School-Based Assessment (SBA).